The First Congregational Church of Colorado Springs was organized and founded in 1874 in conjunction with the founding of Colorado College. The first two ministers of the church,
Rev. Jonathan Edwards and Rev. James Dougherty,
also held positions with the college.
The present building on the corner of St. Vrain and N. Tejon was completed in 1889 at an estimated cost of $40,000. Its design is in the Richardsonian Romanesque style and is constructed of Colorado Wall Mountain Tuft (rhyolite) quarried near Castle Rock, Colorado. The architect was Henry Rutgers Marshall of New York, acclaimed student of Henry Hobson Richardson, and there is only one other church known to have been designed by him: Arlington Avenue Presbyterian Church in Brooklyn, NY (1905, Arlington Avenue Presbyterian Church – Brooklyn, NY ). The first service in the current building was James Gregg held on 21 July 1889 and the new building soon became a landmark in Colorado Springs.
An early article in the then Weekly Gazette newspaper commented that
“the design of the building is unique and has
attracted much attention and admiration.”
“Surely few churches there are with so many pillars. The many pillars in our portico seem suggestive of the spiritual life of the church within, its strength, its dignity, its peace.”
– Dr. James Gregg, October 1914